There, on the front page of Yahoo, was what was sure to be the biggest news story of the year.
“Bad-boy Actor Pummels Justin Bieber.”
Finally, after tormenting the world for what seems like years, some actor had taken care of Bieber once and for all. It was probably Nicholas Cage. Cage doesn’t seem to have a lot going on lately. Add that pent-up crazy to repeatedly hearing Bieber’s “Boyfriend,” and you have a situation prime for a Cage beat down.
Clearly, I had no choice but to click on the story.
Instead of a story describing Nicholas Cage screaming “Swaggie this!” as he unleashed a fury of fists on Bieber’s prepubescent face, I found a much less pleasant surprise. This was not a news story. This was just Bieber’s new video.
I had been sucked in by a misleading title. Some tricky writer at Yahoo had done their best to get more reads by crafting a perfectly sneaky headline.
After my initial disappointment dissipated, I came to realize something. I could also gain readers by using this technique. It doesn’t matter what I write. All that matters is the headline.
I began to study this headline carefully. All of the elements of a sensational story were there. You had an “important” figure. You had a terribly dramatic story. Combine the two and you are certain to get a great number of incredibly confused and mildly upset readers.
Finding someone more popular than Bieber for my headline would be hard. His soulful voice and ambiguous gender have made him the most popular singer in the world. In fact, only one other singer has the same level of voice and gender confusion as Bieber. Only one person could be as popular.
Lady Gaga.
While Bieber would have been enough to get a few clicks for Yahoo, they added a mystery. Who was the “bad-boy actor?” More than anything, I wanted to know who it was that beat him up. Even a person who could not care less about Bieber would be curious.
Following this, I added my own mystery. Whatever was going to happen, Gaga would be doing it with a mystery man. People would see it and immediately have a million questions. Is it her boyfriend? Is her boyfriend Justin Bieber? Is her boyfriend the one who beat up Justin Bieber? Does having a boyfriend make Lady Gaga a heterosexual or homosexual? These questions would lead to hundreds, nay, thousands of readers.
But what would Gaga and her mystery boy toy be doing? It has to be fantastical enough to draw people to it. If the headline had been “Bad-boy Actor Buys Justin Bieber an Ice Cream Cone,” no one would care. It has to be crazy.
Drug use is too common. Dog fighting is too Michael Vick. Wrestling zoo animals is too unbelievable. After a bit of work, I had it.
“Lady Gaga and Mystery Man Arrested After Hot Air Balloon Joy Ride*”
Of course, as a responsible journalist, I feel compelled to add the following disclaimer:
*Lady Gaga has not actually been linked to a mystery man and, to my knowledge, has never been arrested for any hot air balloon related crimes. It is a situation that is possible, though. Just imagine it. What a huge story that would be. I guess that’s probably why you clicked on this post in the first place. You thought you were about to read a huge story.
Now I feel slightly responsible to give you a real story. I just ate a Hershey’s Bliss bar for the first time and it’s pretty good. Not great, but pretty good. I know it’s not as good as the Gaga story, but at least you know of a pretty decent candy bar. I think we can all count this as a win.
Maybe a headline like “Gaga beats up Justin while on a balloon ride” could be your sequel 🙂
LikeLike
If people will read it, I’ll use it. I have no problem lying to people to get more readers.
LikeLike
Dear Nathan,
Impressive misleading Nathan. Your choice in what is or is not good candy has already been brought into question, so the Hershey’s Bliss bar stuff doesn’t impress me.”At least you know of a pretty decent candy bar”? …please. All we know is that it is probably about as good as the other crappy candy you like. I expect a real story next time.
Sincerely, Tired of Being Lied To
LikeLike
Dear Tired of Being Lied To,
I promise I will never lie again. I am nothing if not an honest and trustworthy person who will always deliver truth. Never again will I mislead people.
On an unrelated note, be sure to read my latest post “Sasquatch Steals Bob Costas’ Banana, Costas Vows Revenge.” It is a 100% true story with no lie anywhere in there.
Sincerely,
Nathan
LikeLike
Dear Nathan,
Yeah…and your candy choices still stink.
Sincerely, Realist
LikeLike
Rude.
LikeLike
You’re pretty crafty there, slick! Your headline caught my attention. Well done!
PS eating a Hershey’s bar is way better than anything related to lady gaga!
-Good one, Roly! Made me laugh. 🙂
LikeLike
Haha! Sucker!
LikeLike
I’m heading off now. To grab a candy bar. Because I need one. And because you said so…
🙂
LikeLike
lady gaga é muito bunita, adoro os shows
LikeLike
Sim, Gaga e muito linda mas tenho nunca ouvida uma Gaga canta.
LikeLike
Love LadyGaGa
LikeLike
Congrats on FP!
LikeLike
Thank you.
LikeLike
Ah, and here I was hoping to read about Lady Gaga getting arrested.
So very misleading. So very misleading indeed.
And, Justin Bieber could use a beating by a Bad-Boy actor. It would do him some good. And, give us something to laugh at.
Love, Lilly.
LikeLike
Maybe we should call Sean Penn. He might do it.
LikeLike
Yes, that’s true. He might.
Let us call him!
LikeLike
Oh man. I almost cried from laughing. Speaking of Gaga, have you seen this YouTube video? http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cTFh8LCBZeQ
Makes me proud to be a UO grad.
LikeLike
Lady Gaga will come to my city of Vilnius later this month!
LikeLike
Congratulations. Don’t let her near any airborne transportation.
LikeLike
The reference to Lady Gaga got me to visit. You were succesful there. Of course, the fact that you were just hoe-ing for readers means I’ll never visit again.
LikeLike
You will never visit again… UNLESS I TRICK YOU AGAIN! Challenge accepted! Also, I prefer the term “jezebelling” over “hoe-ing.” Just a thought for any future mildly rude comments you would like to send my way.
LikeLike
I can’t believe I totally fell for that. Actually, I can. Famous person? Check. Odd story? Check. Title making bajillions of readers suddenly curious? Check.
LikeLike
Haha! Mission accomplished.
LikeLike
False advertising is brilliant, and unlike *sorry* up there, I’ll be back … if for no other reason than to see what candy you eat next
LikeLike
Well thank you. Spoiler alert: it will be a sugar free coffee hard candy. It won’t be great.
LikeLike
ABCnews.com has a good one this afternoon: “Gabby Douglas’ 2 Mothers Watch Her Make Olympic History” like Gabby Douglas is from a same-sex household, when it’s actually that…(spoiler)…she lived with another family in Iowa for 2 years while she trained for the Olympics.
LikeLike
The only way that would be better if they had said her “alleged” two mothers watched her. No way I wouldn’t read that.
LikeLike
True, but I was duped as is. Double duped since I read the Bieber thing too. Triple…I was here…oh my! Maybe I need to think more before I click. 🙂
LikeLike
Well, click on over to my blog to read about “OPRAH WINFREY CAUGHT IN LOVE TRIANGLE WITH A BEST FRIEND AND A LOVER!” please
LikeLike
DO IT!
LikeLike
I feel like I’ve just been ‘Punked’.
LikeLike
You have. Sucker.
LikeLike
I can’t think of two less relevant entities than Gaga and Beiber, yet you make their irrelevance magnificently relevant!
LikeLike
Wait just one gosh darned second. IRRELEVANT?! Clearly you haven’t hear Bieber’s new single.
LikeLike
My original contention stands 🙂
LikeLike
Great post, Nathan. I love what you did with the headline and you’re right, I checked this out to see what happened with that balloon. I’m not mildly pissed, but thrilled to discover the truth behind your article. Excellent job!
LikeLike
Thank you for taking my prank so gracefully.
LikeLike
I knew the story was not true, because Lady Gaga would have escaped arrest by jumping out of the air balloon with a parachute made of meat.
LikeLike
I don’t feel like a meat parachute is very practical. It doesn’t seem like the most effective material for preventing a fall.
LikeLike
Agree, jumping with a meat parachute would likely turn you into a meat ball, but since when did Lady Gaga became practical?
LikeLike
That is a fantastic point and one that no one can dispute.
LikeLike
In a hot air balloon, wouldn’t a meat parachute likely turn into a steak parachute due to its close proximity to the giant burner in the middle of the gondola?
LikeLike
It depends how high that balloon is. I doubt that Gaga is good enough to control a balloon that high up, so it probably would not. Of course, I would not have thought she could do most of the stuff she has done, so…
LikeLike
I love it – good show! I have never heard of a Hershey’s Bliss Bar though. Maybe they can make that the next thing added to a DQ blizzard. Se how I tied that in to my blog post today? 🙂
http://thumbtravels.wordpress.com/2012/08/03/thumb-travels-to-dairy-queen/
LikeLike
I would eat it. Also, I will read your post. I’m generous that way.
LikeLike
I was snagged by the title just like everyone else and laughed all the way through. Brilliant! Thanks.
LikeLike
No, thank you.
LikeLike
read your post, sob. thanks for share
LikeLike
You’re welcome, I guess.
LikeLike
Brilliant article! Actually enjoyed it more than if it had been about Lady Gaga and a mystery man:)
LikeLike
Haha! Very clever. 🙂
LikeLike
I care not about Gaga, Bieber, hot air balloons and Hershey bars (except that I did click the intriguing link!), but you managed to slip one of my favorite words into this post: fantastical. Kudos to you.
LikeLike
I don’t understand how you can say you don’t care about Hershey bars. I don’t know if you have ever had one, but it tastes pretty good. Either way, thanks for appreciating fantastical.
LikeLike
I don’t like this character !!
LikeLike
Congrats on yet another FPing! You’ve obviously latched on to the secret to scamming the FP Panel of Judges into visiting your blog.
Great post!
I once did something similar with my post entitled “Big ‘Uns”… I’m still getting a dependable trickle of hits on that one!
LikeLike
Just read this freshly pressed blog: http://anniegetyournotepad.com/2012/08/02/what-jonah-lehrer-tells-us-about-todays-journalism-industry
Seems both of you are onto the fierce competition for clicks and attention. I was wondering how an article on Lady Gaga airballooning could be Freshly Pressed. Now I understand, and I’m glad I followed the lure to a click.
After further ‘research,’ though, I learned the “mystery man” is actually Mystery Man, an up and coming rapper/techno artist that is collaborating with Lady Gaga on her next album. They were airballooning for inspiration.
LikeLike
Everyone should check out Mystery Man’s new album “Who Dat?” everywhere music is sold. It’s a can’t miss.
LikeLike
Sample from the title track:
Just me and Lady Gaga in the air,
Gotta ask who dat there?
Little dots, little people down below.
Look up, and say, yo,
Who dat? Uh. Yeah. Who dat there?
It’s a bird. It’s a plane. It’s just insane.
Who dat? Who dat there?
LikeLike
Man! U where sucker punched right in the gut….?
LikeLike